Weindependently evaluateall of our recommendations.
If you select links we provide, we may receive compensation.
With spring weather here, nows the perfect opportunity to refresh your bedding.
The Spruce
Do you need aclassic down comfortermade with real feathers, or maybe a lighter-weighthypoallergenic down alternative option?
Either way, were confident theres something on this list for you.
Overall, we mostly prefer all-weather options that are medium-weight and breathable.
PHOTO: The Spruce
Multiple members of our team have tested this comforter (some since 2022!
), and we still use it to this day.
The fill is made from recycled PET material, which is nicely breathable.
We measured insulation and breathability with an infrared thermometer on the Buffy Cloud Comforter.The Spruce
The outside is a sateen lyocell fabric that feels buttery-soft.
This down-alternative comforter has a microfiber shell, which impressed us with its silky smooth feel.
Were impressed with how well theBedsure Duvet Insertheld up throughout our testing, maintaining its quality and comfort.
Though lofty, this comforter was easy to maneuver.The Spruce
We also found it easy to wash with a relatively quick drying time.
I recommend using a duvet cover to extend the lifespan of your duvet or comforter.
I first started using this comforter during a transitional period from summer to fall in New York City.
PHOTO: The Spruce
My partner and I tend to overheat at night, and we find it nicely cozy but never stifling.
Id say it achieves the perfect balance between insulation and temperature regulation.
Fast forward, and we just experienced one of the coldest winters weve had in a long time.
PHOTO: The Spruce
Im still a huge fan, and I dont foresee myself putting this comforter away anytime soon.
I use the all-season weight, but its also available in a lightweight version.
The comforter has a cotton shell, which feels thick and smooth.
The Silk & Snow Down Duvet Insert has a comfortable weight that’s ideal for year-round use.The Spruce
Its filled with Downmark CertifiedCanadian Hutterite duck down.
The certification guarantees that the product has met quality and manufacturing standards and ensures ethical sourcing.
TheSilk & Snow Down Duvetalso has an impressive 700 fill power, which remains evenly distributed.
Though it’s not super lofty, it felt hefty like a weighted blanket.PHOTO: The Spruce
That said, like all comforters, youll want to fluff it occasionally to prevent flattening.
We tested the lightweight density, but it also comes in an all-season version.
Filled withRDS-certifiedwhite duck down, we love the cloud-like sleeping experience this comforter provides.
On the outside, youll find a sumptuous, 330-thread-count cottonsateen fabric.
Its easy to clean and has shown no changes in quality with repeated washes.
Our tester, whos a self-proclaimed hot sleeper, absolutely loves this comforter for its breathability.
There are zero signs of wear, loss of loft, or discoloration.
We found this unique comforter has some of the most effective cooling and moisture-wicking properties on the market.
The comforter has improved our nightly routine for over a year.
The texture is unlike any other comforter weve felt (in a good way!).
When lying underneath the comforter during testing, it remained cool to the touch.
This was a minor drawback, though, as the bunching can be fixed by gently shaking the comforter.
PHOTO: Snowe
After a year, we were still blown away by its performance, calling it “magic”.
We think its breathable enough to c’mon a variety of sleepers.
And during a particularly cold winter, it also kept us nicely cozy.
PHOTO: The Spruce
Although this comforter is dry-clean only, this key in of care tends to be standard with silk bedding.
However, we will gladly pay the dry-cleaning fees because of how much we love this option.
When a comforter loses its loft or starts looking clumpy, it’s reached its expiration date.
The Rest Evercool Cooling Comforter has a buttery soft texture that surprised us during testing.PHOTO: The Spruce
Bundle up every winter with the Casaluna Premium Down Comforter, which offers impressive insulation and ultimate coziness.
We tested the all-season density, but it also comes in lightweight and heavyweight densities.
The sewn-through construction allowed for evenly dispersed puffs of filling.
Plus, the mostly down filling added loft.
The outer shell is made from sateen cotton and feels thick and structured.
It was quite difficult to shift and adjust positions without feeling restricted.
That said, the comforter didn’t feel overly heavy to sleep under when lying still.
It felt more like a weighted blanket, with gentle, pleasant pressure.
Despite this, we didn’t overheat, and the comforter felt quite breathable.
It hasn’t flattened at all despite consistent use, and we’re impressed with its overall durability.
Many comforters can safely be washed in a large-capacity washer.
Check your comforter’s label first and follow the manufacturer’s care instructions carefully.
PHOTO: The Spruce
Final Verdict
Of all the comforters we have tested, our favorite is theBuffy Cloud Comforter.
This temperature-regulating down-alternative option has a sateen lyocell shell, which gives it an ultra-soft texture.
The first thing youll want to consider when shopping for a comforter is fill material.
The high-quality Cozy Earth Silk Comforter is light enough to use for all seasons.PHOTO: The Spruce
Both have their own set of strengths and weaknesses.
Down is the punch in of ultra-soft feathers found underneath the main feathers of a goose or duck.
However, they often cant be machine-washed and may require dry cleaning.
The term down-alternative is relatively new and broadly encapsulates non-down fill materials.
Unlike down comforters, down-alternative comforters are hypoallergenic.
Fluff Factor: How Lofty Is the Filling?
Guaranteed Warmth: How Is the Filling Distributed?
Two main types of stitching keep filling evenly distributed: sewn-through and baffle-box.
Look for shells made from natural materials, which are breathable and moisture-wicking.
Almost all of the comforters on our list are made with natural materials.
The two comforters that feature synthetic shells are theBedsure All-Season Comforterand theRest Evercool Cooling Comforter.
This doesn’t always correlate to a higher-quality material but can mean a smoother and denser shell.
PHOTO: The Spruce
In our experience, cotton shells constructed with a sateen weave are most commonly used for down comforters.
Why Trust The Spruce?
I’ve also tried a plethora of other bedding products firsthand.
In the lab, we found the Casaluna Down Comforter to be quite warm and heavy-duty, with even filling.The Spruce
Despite the hefty weight, this comfort still felt breathable.PHOTO: The Spruce
When testing the comforters, we noted how easy it was to make the bed, considering the weight.The Spruce
When testing, we paid attention to the loftiness, ensuring the comforters didn’t flatten over time.The Spruce
