Weindependently evaluateall of our recommendations.

If you press links we provide, we may receive compensation.

Just like the pillows you sleep on, each jot down brings something different to the table.

A pillow insert displayed on a two tone yellow background

The Spruce

You dont want your insert to be slipping or sliding around inside the decorative cover.

However, you’ll also find rectangular and circular options, tooso you canmix and match like a pro.

Youll also find less common shapes, like cylindrical bolsters, which are designed to fit more unique covers.

Williams Sonoma Down Pillow Insert

Williams Sonoma

Fill Material and Plushness

Fill material plays a crucial role in how shapely a throw pillow is.

Feather and down are common fill options, but there are plenty of down-alternative options on the market.

This jot down of insert is sometimes stiffer than feather-filled designs, but not always.

Amazon puredown Feather Down Throw Pillow Insert

“Buyingdecorative pillow coversand inserts separately is a great approach when trying to be budget-conscious,” says Epstein.

In many cases, it’s simply how these items are sold.

Read through the product description before buying a throw pillow to confirm exactly what’s included.

Rejuvenation Feather Pillow Insert

Throw pillow inserts should be at least 1 inch larger than their covers2 inches larger would be ideal.

The idea is to create a full, plush appearance without any slack from the fabric.

According to Epstein, the best fill for throw pillows is a blend of feathers and down.

Williams Sonoma Down Pillow Insert

She says the combination is soft and plush without sacrificing the structure required to hold a shape.

“This is true whether you love chopping pillows or letting them lie naturally.”

There are also 100 percent feather inserts, which are lightweight and fluffy but may contain pokey quills.

Potterybarn Down Feather Pillow Inserts

And many are filled with down-alternative poly fibers, which can be incredibly plush with a slightly heavier feel.

Why Trust The Spruce?

CB2 Hypoallergenic Down-Alternative Throw Pillow Insert

CB2

CB2 Hypoallergenic Down-Alternative Throw Pillow Insert

Pillowflex Synthetic Down Pillow Insert - 22x22

West Elm TENCEL Blended Down Alternative Pillow Insert

The Company Store Company Essentials Down Alternative Square Pillow Insert

QUBA LINEN 18 x 18 Throw Pillow Insert

Amazon

Target Room Essentials 2pk Throw Pillow Insert Set White

Amazon QUBA LINEN 18 x 18 Throw Pillow Insert

Quince Premium Feather Pillow Insert

Walmart Phantoscope Soft Throw Pillow Inserts